Conflict or coincidence?
COLUMBIA, 2/3/13 (Beat Byte) -- Is it coincidence two people leading a push to tear down eight historic homes along Providence Road in the Grasslands neighborhood also own a vacant lot (photo) in the path of the bulldozers that could make them over three hundred thousand dollars?
That's what neighbors fighting the proposed demolitions -- otherwise known as Phase 1 and Phase 2 of the Providence Improvement Project -- are asking.
Grasslands residents and others attended a packed meeting
in the new City Hall chambers, to debate the Providence proposal Thursday night. With lines out the door, Historic Preservation Commission chair Brian Treece
-- whose group hosted the event -- had to delay the start time to accommodate the crowd.Three-hour tour
After three hours of public testimony and presentations about the current plan and alternatives, it was clear city administrators were up to their old tricks, stifling debate and meddling with democracy. Then-city manager Bill Watkins had reportedly asked then-City Councilwoman Laura Nauser not to talk to neighbors so his staff could have "maximum" flexibility to negotiate a deal.
The deal: Spend millions buying property, tearing down homes, widening Providence, adding crosswalks and installing traffic lights. Meeting attendees seemed to like the crosswalks and lights, but hated tearing down the homes. It would scalp the Grasslands they exclaimed, rip off its crown, and destroy Columbia's most picturesque gateway.
What's worse: many neighbors didn't even know about the 2-phase plan and felt left out of the process.
Who knew what and when
eventually emerged, but not before Treece and fellow commissioners grilled city traffic engineer Scott Bitterman
, who did the old Jackie Gleason/Ralph Kramden "homina homina" routine
when asked "whose plan is it to tear down all these houses?
"Who made up the plan? Where did you get it?" Treece asked.
"The Missouri Department of Transportation (MoDOT)," Bitterman shimmied. Then: No, not MoDOT -- maybe the city. No, no -- not the city. MoDOT. Yeah, that's it. MoDOT.
Then Treece referenced a constituent email from former 5th Ward Councilwoman Helen Anthony
that spilled the beans. Three men were behind the plan, Anthony wrote: John Ott, Robbie Price,
and City of Columbia public works director John Glascock
. Ott and Price served as presidents of the Grasslands Neighborhood Association while pushing the plans. They are also part-owners of a vacant lot on the corner of Burnam and Providence Roads City Hall is offering $400,000 to buy.
Price owns the vacant lot with Ott, Columbia Business Times
publisher Al Germond
and his partner, Dave Baugher
, another Grasslands neighbor.
Even more galling, Ott and Price have nothing to lose. Unlike their neighbors, they own vacant land -- no house to demolish, no wrenching goodbyes to a piece of CoMo history, no emotional upheaval. Just an oddly-shaped lot worth a whole lot more than it would be if Uncle Mo hadn't come calling with his taxpayer checkbook.
Coincidence -- or conflict?
Price and Ott are likable people, all the more reason their neighbors are befuddled.
Price is one of the most personable fellows you're ever gonna meet. He's charming, gracious, kind, and has a twinkle in his eye whenever he talks to you.
Ott is humble, soft-spoken, almost diffident, never saying a mean word about anyone. He's also the closest thing Columbia has to a patron saint of historic preservation, which makes his involvement in the Providence demolitions supremely ironic.
Both Ott and Price are also among Columbia's most successful men, the kind of people you might hold up to your kids. They're leaders, by virtue not only of money and power, but charm, affability, and smarts. Without Ott's vision and ability to implement grand plans, downtown Columbia wouldn't be half what it is today. And I can't think of a better neighborhood representative than Price.
Still, they do own the lot -- bought it back in 2003 County records indicate, with Germond and Baugher.
Coincidentally, people keep saying the Providence Improvement Project kicked off about a decade ago. "Neighbors should know about it by now," supporters have griped. "We've been plannin' it nigh on ten years."
Or since right around the time the four men bought the lot.
Price, Ott, and Baugher owe their neighbors a choice: either sell the lot or abstain from further involvement in any Providence plans. Maybe even step down from neighborhood leadership. Phase 1 and 2, meanwhile, should be scrapped.
Conflict or coincidence, the Providence Improvement Project is tainted.
-- Mike Martin for the Columbia Heart Beat